Fishnhunt New Zealand hunting and Fishing Forum Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
 
| Forum 1995-2002 | Forum 2002-2006 | To Fishnhunt Mainpage |
  Home Donate Advertise HelpSearchLoginRegister Historic Photos  
 
Pages: 1 2 3 ... 81
Send Topic Print
Poisoning of Stewart island (Read 40345 times)
Rogers.270
Forum Senior
****
Online


Lives for the tops

Posts: 704
nelson lakes
Gender: male
Poisoning of Stewart island
Oct 31st, 2012 at 3:41pm
 
PLAN TO RID STEWART ISLAND OF MAMMAL PESTS - Gareth Morgan, a rich and powerful New Zealand businessman, has a dream. He has teamed up with Department of Conservation, and some locals, and is advocating ridding Stewart Island of mammal pests. Click here Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register to view this short video about what this dream will mean to the local wildlife, should the eradication programme go ahead.  400 local residents have one week remaining to vote YES or NO on the proposal.
Back to top
 

Balls Out
 
IP Logged
 
cleaky
Donor Member
*****
Offline


... pass me my 16 gauge,
I'll handle this ...

Posts: 11383
Southland
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #1 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 3:50pm
 
He should stick to talking crap about the economyand messing up peoples kiwisavers and stay the hell out of the environment.  Roll Eyes
Back to top
 

It's ok if you disagree with me. I can't force you to be right.
 
IP Logged
 
Victor
Active Member
***
Offline


Deer are where you (can't)
find them

Posts: 184
Christchurch
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #2 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:05pm
 
At the risk of showing my ignorance and stirring sh!t, I need to ask - what is the problem that most hunters are concerned about? The culling of a decent herd of whitetail or the inadvertent poisoning of native species? I must say that I'm personally quite happy to give up any hope of shooting a whitetail in SI if the outcome is to have a one-of-a-kind native sanctuary. The hunting sacrifice is worth the biodiversity stability, in my opinion. However, if the problem is purely the method of choice, then I empathise with everyones' concerns.

I'm not trying to undermine anyone here, just want to see what exactly the issue is...  Cheesy
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
264KMagic
Forum Font
*****
Offline


I Love The FishNhunt Forum

Posts: 4082
Geraldine
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #3 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:20pm
 
the issue my dear friend victor is quite wide,,it started with a turkey named smith who abandoned our fair shores and sailed to africa,,Rhodesia to be exact,,and started a program of change,,the rest is history and personally i dont like the way this place is heading ,,i therefore am abandoning the  t.i.a. ship

interesting bit of news this morning that there are heaps of maori in aussie,,apparently more than here,,which leaves us with hone  Shocked Shocked
Back to top
 

It is much better to Hit the Animal in the right place, with a Rifle you can shoot well, then to hit it poorly with a Large Calibre..John Nosler
 
IP Logged
 
chris
Global Forum Guide
Donor Member
Staff
*****
Offline


a setter is better!

Posts: 23890
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #4 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:33pm
 
Victor wrote on Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:05pm:
At the risk of showing my ignorance and stirring sh!t, I need to ask - what is the problem that most hunters are concerned about? The culling of a decent herd of whitetail or the inadvertent poisoning of native species? I must say that I'm personally quite happy to give up any hope of shooting a whitetail in SI if the outcome is to have a one-of-a-kind native sanctuary. The hunting sacrifice is worth the biodiversity stability, in my opinion. However, if the problem is purely the method of choice, then I empathise with everyones' concerns.

I'm not trying to undermine anyone here, just want to see what exactly the issue is...  Cheesy

my concern is for everything on the island. the deer are not causing a problem there.
the method, brodi, is a long lasting, very effective indiscriminate killer. its shocking stuff and even doc dislike using it if you believe what they say.
previous island use has resulted in brodi traces showing up in sea life and horrific by kills of native species.
on top of that, it wont work. eradicating anything from anywhere is difficult. from an entire island with lots of visitors? give me a break! Roll Eyes
even the tiny little island sanctuaries with very few visitors are hard to keep pest free.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
leathel
Donor Member
*****
Offline


Hunting / Fishing, Its
all good!!

Posts: 11577
Tuakau, Waikato
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #5 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:38pm
 
Victor wrote on Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:05pm:
At the risk of showing my ignorance and stirring sh!t, I need to ask - what is the problem that most hunters are concerned about? The culling of a decent herd of whitetail or the inadvertent poisoning of native species? I must say that I'm personally quite happy to give up any hope of shooting a whitetail in SI if the outcome is to have a one-of-a-kind native sanctuary. The hunting sacrifice is worth the biodiversity stability, in my opinion. However, if the problem is purely the method of choice, then I empathise with everyones' concerns.

I'm not trying to undermine anyone here, just want to see what exactly the issue is...  Cheesy



Yes wiping out the deer population is part of it, they don't do a lot of harm and have been a source of income for the island for years as well as a resource to those that want to hunt the island

Also a big thing for me is the clean green image we are loosing from mass poisoning of kea, Weka and to a lesser degree a large number of other species, there are other ways to target the cats and rats that don't have long lasting by kills like Brodifacoum has.

I personally think smaller area of targeted heavy pest control and then maintain the area is better than blanket drops

I have been in areas after drops and seen the rotting deer and birds.... It just made me feel sick to the core.

Stuart Island already has great bird life..... what is it going to gain apart from massive by kills
Back to top
 

Multimedia File Viewing and Clickable Links are available for Registered Members only!!  You need to Login or Register
 
IP Logged
 
Victor
Active Member
***
Offline


Deer are where you (can't)
find them

Posts: 184
Christchurch
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #6 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:39pm
 
264KMagic wrote on Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:20pm:
i therefore am abandoning the  t.i.a. ship


I didn't mean to stir that sort of "native" debate...  Lips Sealed

Chris - I guess you're right. And there's plenty of other biodiversity tragedies happening in NZ to worry about. SI is probably doing OK, all-in-all.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
chris
Global Forum Guide
Donor Member
Staff
*****
Offline


a setter is better!

Posts: 23890
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #7 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 5:21pm
 
the bird life is incredible by main land standards, especially kiwi, common as chooks! Grin Grin
brodi is just nasty shit from woe to go. i would never support its use!
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Malhunting
Forum Font
*****
Offline


.300 wsm<br />

Posts: 1738
Mataura
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #8 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 5:52pm
 
Just seems to me that there is to much to loose and nothing to gain, Brodi is a terrible poison to use for this sort of idea and has already shown its devastating affect on everything that comes into contact with it, then there's the time this shit takes to break down, if it does at all.
I honestly don't think there will be a gain in tourism to the island if this plan is even successful in fact if it goes ahead and it does kill most of the islands critters and animals then tourism will decline rapidly especially with hunters.
I hope to go there one day and get a good look at the wild life and kiwis etc and if i get to shoot a Whitetail in the process then that's just a bonus.
SAVE THE ISLAND, SPARE THE POISON!
Back to top
 

<div style=
 
IP Logged
 
chris
Global Forum Guide
Donor Member
Staff
*****
Offline


a setter is better!

Posts: 23890
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #9 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 5:58pm
 
have a look on the doc page guys, there's good info on this topic there. at this stage it sounds like its just an idea put forward by gareth morgen Roll Eyes apparently Lips Sealed
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Malhunting
Forum Font
*****
Offline


.300 wsm<br />

Posts: 1738
Mataura
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #10 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 7:51pm
 
Sounds like he is pushing the idea fairly hard but and all behind closed doors by the looks. Angry
Back to top
 

<div style=
 
IP Logged
 
Max
Donor Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 3071
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #11 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 8:13pm
 
dilettante [ˌdɪlɪˈtɑːntɪ]
n pl -tantes, -tanti [-ˈtɑːntɪ]

1. a person whose interest in a subject is superficial rather than professional
2. (Fine Arts & Visual Arts / Art Terms) a person who loves the arts
adj
(Fine Arts & Visual Arts / Art Terms) of or characteristic of a dilettante
[from Italian, from dilettare to delight, from Latin dēlectāre]
dilettantish , dilettanteish adj
dilettantism , dilettanteism n



Hmmmm
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
export dry
Active Member
***
Online


I Love The FishNhunt Forum

Posts: 28
stewart island
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #12 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 9:07pm
 
good on ya gareth morgan ,poisoning the hole island mite get rid of half the of the rednecks as well
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
benelli
Active Member
***
Offline


I Love The FishNhunt Forum

Posts: 51
Invercargill
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #13 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 9:20pm
 
Nice one Victor.  Why don't we eradicate all introduced animals, birds and fish in NZ while we are at it.  You might not be interested in hunting Stewart Island but plenty of other people are.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Victor
Active Member
***
Offline


Deer are where you (can't)
find them

Posts: 184
Christchurch
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #14 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 9:24pm
 
Easy tiger. I did specify that it was only my opinion and I'm only trying to gauge what others think on the matter.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Max
Donor Member
*****
Offline



Posts: 3071
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #15 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 10:01pm
 
Victor wrote on Oct 31st, 2012 at 4:05pm:
At the risk of showing my ignorance and stirring sh!t, I need to ask - what is the problem that most hunters are concerned about? The culling of a decent herd of whitetail or the inadvertent poisoning of native species? I must say that I'm personally quite happy to give up any hope of shooting a whitetail in SI if the outcome is to have a one-of-a-kind native sanctuary. The hunting sacrifice is worth the biodiversity stability, in my opinion. However, if the problem is purely the method of choice, then I empathise with everyones' concerns.

I'm not trying to undermine anyone here, just want to see what exactly the issue is...  Cheesy



Well, there's the thing, isn't it......IF.

I personally have no major issue with 1080 as a pest control mechanism. What I do have an issue with is whether DoC and others will adequately assess whether the objective is realistically achievable or not.

So I have a concern that it will be adopted 'cos it seems a nice idea, it may not work, and then we've all lost.

Just my view, though.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Victor
Active Member
***
Offline


Deer are where you (can't)
find them

Posts: 184
Christchurch
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #16 - Oct 31st, 2012 at 10:24pm
 
Max wrote on Oct 31st, 2012 at 10:01pm:
What I do have an issue with is whether DoC and others will adequately assess whether the objective is realistically achievable or not.


True - it seems like the science would suggest this is a method destined to fail. Given that DoC employs heaps of scientists, you'd expect thorough evidence-based justification for a move like this...

Don't get me wrong, I've tried to stalk whitetail before and I'd absolutely love to again. I just come from a non-hunting background and so have a broad perspective on the matter.
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
MassiveAttack
Forum Font
*****
Offline


Setting trends in waterfowling
fashion since 2011

Posts: 8420
Canterbury
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #17 - Nov 1st, 2012 at 12:59pm
 
The whitetail are not doing any harm to the enviroment so there is no need to exterminate them. That's my opinion.
Back to top
 

This is my rifle, there are many like it but this one is mine.  Without my rifle I am useless, without me it is useless.
 
IP Logged
 
Jim46
Just Joined
*
Offline


I Love The FishNhunt Forum

Posts: 8
Dunedin
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #18 - Nov 1st, 2012 at 2:42pm
 
Note there is also discussion on this under "Rakiura whitetail under threat" and also on the DoC page
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Jim46
Just Joined
*
Offline


I Love The FishNhunt Forum

Posts: 8
Dunedin
Gender: male
Re: Poisoning of Stewart island
Reply #19 - Nov 1st, 2012 at 2:54pm
 
For an article on the risks of aerial brodifacoum to the marine environment and island ecology visit the website 1080science.co.nz "Brodifacoum and Ulva Island"
Back to top
 
 
IP Logged
 
Pages: 1 2 3 ... 81
Send Topic Print