Prior to the last election I tried to express and highlight my fears that Trout farming was being secretly planned and unfortunately I failed to raise any real concern amongst the angling fraternity and distinctly got the opinion that a new generation of anglers were not really concerned.
Sandfords Fishery is now calling for trout farming to allowed and the Chairman of the National Party is a substantial shareholder in Sandfords.
The same concerns that we had last time Salminoid farming / imports of fresh meat mooted by those who wanted to make money at the cost of our wild fisheries. Some of those were. Commercialisation of the resource. Poached trout are sold now, with a legitimate market the pressure will increase dramatically. The importation of foreign fish with the accompanying diseases and possible genetic defects which have the potential to decimate our wild trout populations. I understand that NZs trout fishery has been self contained for very many years. To the extent that our fish have no resistance to many of the diseases that are now common overseas. PS I cant actually see what the fuss over trout is all about. They dont have much taste. Cant fight to save themselves & their pursuit is govened by a ridiculous amount of rules
How will allowing Trout farms affect the resource? Fish are already farmed here and are released into a lot of places. I would have thought the farms would ease the pressure on poached fish being sold not the other way round as there would be heaps of legal fish for sale. I could be wrong but isn't Taupo the only true wild hatchery in the world? As for the diseases, well they are dealt with else where so wouldn't they be dealt with here? It does not bother me either way really, just asking some questions.
I can't really envision a time when I'm not shooting something.
Australia has had trout farms for years, and it hasn't ended civilisation there (though obviously, other things have!).
And NZ already has salmonid farms. I can't think of any diseases that impact trout that don't impact salmon, so that horse has well and truly bolted.
Though I am kind of disturbed that a politician who is a substantial shareholder in a company that wants to introduce farms is permitted to have a say or has influence in the decision making process.
Hell, I got a contract at the IRD and had to resign as treasurer of a club I belong to - as it breaches the IRDs potential conflict of interest rules. Politicians should be held to the same standard! (Tui).
There's a fine line between fishing and just standing on the shore like an id10t. (Steven Wright)
IP Logged
Beaker
Forum Font
Offline
very happy with my life
Posts: 1872
Location: Auckland NZ
Joined: Nov 12th, 2006
Gender:
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #5 - May 15th, 2012 at 6:19pm
Poaching is the big bogey on this one and really the only issue though in general farmed trout are pretty cheap so unlikely to be much of an effect.
Can't see much of a market here really though the average Kiwi doesn't really go for small fish and thats what trout farms produce. 1lb rainbows smoked and fresh which are usually cooked and served whole.
IP Logged
Werewolf
Full Member
Offline
I Love outdoor activities
Posts: 365
Location: wellington
Joined: May 17th, 2011
Gender:
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #6 - May 25th, 2012 at 8:46pm
I think you will find that this is more about tit for tat, Fed farmers get all pissed whenever F&G start making noises about water quality and run off. evertime they do , fed farmers roll out the trout farm issue
IP Logged
chris
Donor Member
Offline
a setter is better!
Posts: 25697
Joined: Aug 3rd, 2007
Gender:
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #7 - May 28th, 2012 at 11:44am
at the risk of sounding ignorant, and im not a trout fisho so done really know much about the issue, i dont really understand the problem with trout farms surly poaching is a very minor issue, you could only sell them under the rules? disease? btmo is a fish dude and says they share any diseases with farmed salmon so dont see the problem there. am i missing something here???
IP Logged
Benelli boy
Donor Member
Offline
I Love The FishNhunt Forum
Posts: 1411
Location: Canterbury
Joined: Nov 4th, 2007
Gender:
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #8 - May 30th, 2012 at 10:33pm
I will state outright that I draw my income (wage only) from fish farming. Therefore any thoughts I share here are open to arguement and as long as it is kept civil, I will attempt to answer any questions I can. If I have no knowledge of the issues raised around any questions asked I will say so. From my point of view, I draw your attention to this thread. http://www.fishnhunt.co.nz/forum/YaBB.cgi?num=1318114231
You will notice that the contributor threatens all kinds of world ending doom but the thread just stopped! My point is that even the doom sayers have nothing to present some time after armageddon was predicted.
I have nothing to gain out of this arguement beyond my sad weekly wage. However I have been involved in making small Salmon into big Salmon for the last ten years. I am happy that what we do has no affect on the wild fishery. I don't see that trout would be any different beyond the water use arguement.
Cheers Chris.
To be old & wise, you must first be young & stupid!
IP Logged
chris
Donor Member
Offline
a setter is better!
Posts: 25697
Joined: Aug 3rd, 2007
Gender:
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #9 - May 31st, 2012 at 12:04am
on thinking about this two possible aspects concern me. 1, more water use from rivers? i wouldn't support that as i feel our rivers are under enough pressure already. 2, that if a commercial market for trout existed a quota of wild stock may be approved to be taken. i certainly wouldn't support that!
IP Logged
Benelli boy
Donor Member
Offline
I Love The FishNhunt Forum
Posts: 1411
Location: Canterbury
Joined: Nov 4th, 2007
Gender:
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #10 - Jun 1st, 2012 at 12:33am
Totally agree on the water use issue Chris. Here in Canterbury we are ripping out all of our windbreak plantings and putting in more wells. It will be a bastard when milkfat doesn't pay anymore and nobody can afford to run pumps for irrigators to keep our land moist and the cows fat. I believe that most of the Canterbury Plains will end up in the Pacific Ocean. That aside, fish seem to grow better in a saltwater environment and certainly taste better. Hopefully further encroachment by exploiters on OUR freshwater resource will be shot down in flames. Politically though, The national income from dairy is too good to ignore and is the only thing that separates New Zealand from Greece financially!
To be old & wise, you must first be young & stupid!
Farmed Trout dont taste that good. Having seen many a farmed trout coming out of the pond, you'd not want to eat one anyway , slimy, pale sickly looking diseased and fungus ridden would be a suitable description.
Bon appetit.
“We either make ourselves miserable, or we make ourselves strong. The amount of work is the same.”
It was never going to happen. Just gets occasionally rolled out so some parties can publicise it then take the credit for apparently stopping it. Now everyone can move on to an issue that is actually relevent and important, without more political grandstanding Dan
IP Logged
Alan
Administrator Donor Member Staff
Offline
I Love The FishNhunt Forum
Posts: 4944
Location: Turangi
Joined: Nov 5th, 2006
Re: Trout Farming push is now on Reply #14 - Jun 9th, 2012 at 7:57am
I don't understand where you are coming from. When the president of the national party makes the play for it and he is a major shareholder in a huge fishing company that has dozens of mussel farms in the Marlborough sounds and he says they want to turn them into trout farms..you need to grandstand.. its the noise from anglers that has seen it countered... the only reason you are not surrounded by trout farms now is because of all the grandstanding done in the 1970's.... .